Homemade Oreos

Yikes, this is a busy time of year. I’m really feeling the effects of less sleep – goal for tonight: 7 hours or more!

Wednesday started off with a cup of coffee and a freezing cold enjoyable 8 mile run with Alma. Note to self: if my hands start to go numb, shaking them vigorously brings back feeling. Good to know, even though it makes me look like a crazy person.

Moving on to breakfast: I heart winter citrus fruits. Especially grapefruit & orange!

Grapefruit and orange

And a hearty slice of Eli Zabar’s bread topped with pb & j.


Plus a little more (decaf) coffee:


Day was hectic, so lunch was eaten at my desk. But at least it was a fabulous salad!


  • romaine, mixed greens, shredded carrots, mushrooms, onions
  • roasted brussels sprouts, sample of roasted parsnip
  • chickpeas & kidney beans (~1/3 cup)
  • sprinkle of feta cheese, sunflower seeds, dried cranberries, whole grain croutons
  • balsamic vinaigrette
  • Yum!

Afternoon snackeroos were a few strawberries/piece of pound cake dipped in chocolate sauce.


and an oikos greek yogurt for protein!


I finally got out of the office a little after 7pm and made my way uptown. Fun evening plans: Laundry! Hah. I actually really, really dislike doing laundry. I try to put it off as long as possible….

Once I made the initial trek to the laundromat, I dug into a special treat. Awhile back, Kath’s blog was offering up a very special deal: $25 gift certificate for anything at her Open Sky store. I jumped on the bandwagon and snapped up 2 jars of organic nutzo for myself. This stuff is amazingly crunchy! In addition to peanuts, it also contains: sunflower seeds, hazelnuts, almonds, cashews, and flax seeds. Holy, legume.


I really only wanted to have nut butter for dinner, but in attempts to make it a little more balanced I made a snacking plate: sliced apple, carrot sticks, and triscuits. With lots of nutzo!

Tasting plate


I ended my night very sweetly – with a few of the homemade oreos I made on Tuesday! Homemade oreos? Can it be true? YES. Apparently, I don’t have enough on my plate, so I’ve started re-creating the products of huge corporations. Twinkie, you’re next….

Just kidding.

Anyway, I based these cookies on a recipe by Joanne Chang of Flour Bakery (must.go.there.soon). My recipe came out of a book called Baking from the Heart, but the Boston Globe published a similar homemade oreos recipe this summer.

Mix the melted chocolate, butter, sugar, egg, and vanilla with the dry ingredients. Use quality chocolate and cocoa powder – you’ll taste the difference in these cookies.

homemade oreos

The trickiest part of the process: shaping the cookie dough into logs, chilling it (preferably overnight), and slicing it into thin disks.

homemade oreo dough

The cookie wafers baked up nice and crispy!

homemade oreo cookies

And then I made the filling and shaped that into a log. You don’t even want to know how much butter and confectioner’s sugar I used. The oreo filling was sliced and sandwiched between two chocolate cookies.

homemade oreo filling

Ta-da! This recipe made a lot of cookies – approximately 50 – so I’m going to be nice and share them with my co-workers and friends. However, I might stash away a few for myself. I have a feeling they won’t last long!

homemade oreos

New articles from Running Shorts:

The Atkins Diet for runners? Matt explores low-carb running.

And I recently reviewed John L. Parker’s cult classic, Once A Runner. FYI – It’s no longer out of print!

Question: What “commercial” food product would you like to try re-creating at home? My oreos aren’t exactly healthy, but at least I can pronounce every ingredient in them 🙂

  • Eve

    I can’t believe you ran outside in this weather!! It’s so freezing. Eli Zabar makes my favorite bread -it’s the health loaf, so delicious!

  • Such a good post! For the following reasons:

    1) Your chocolate dipped snacky goodness
    2) The Nutzo spread. What a blend of nutty goodness, like NYC!
    3)Your recreation of a famous processed snack.

    If you could make Twinkies healthy enough so crazies (ahem, Dan White) who shoot progressive Assembly men (ahem ahem, Harvey Milk) can’t use sugary treats as a scapegoat for their horrendous crimes…well, then that would be fabulous!

  • Lisa

    Great post! I really enjoy reading your post and such great ideas.


  • Holy….! I almost cursed those look so good.

    Homemade oreos sound like heaven itself and I’m jealous of your co-workers. haha

  • MEGANNNN…those homemade oreos look TDF. the best part is…i don’t even like the frosting, so i could just make the cookie part and eat that. i’m excited!

    i feel ya on lack of sleep…these past two weeks i have definitely fallen off the bandwagon. here’s to getting back on and working it out!

    love you girl – and i am totally jealous you got the $25 for the nuttzo! i am so intrigued by that stuff!

  • I love the snack plate with nuttzo. So much better than just going at it with a spoon(which I could totally do)

    I wish I could make my own “fake meat”. It’s weird but I love the flavor of lightlife products and even though they’re all natural I don’t know how to recreate that flavor

  • The Oreos look great … I wonder if I could get my 5 year old son to give up (he gets one small packet a month) the store bought Oreos 🙂 I feel sick and guilty every time I see him eat one of those things.

    As for what commercial product I’ve been making – “Nutella” … made with Almonds+Walnuts+Cashews+Coconut Oil+Organic Chocolate … much better and I can choose the consistency and sweetness.

  • Okay, these homemade Oreos are seriously impressive. My corner bakery makes these once in a while and I had one once and it was amazing. Props to you for going to all that work! Wowzas! i have to recommend an awesome cookie recipe I made last week…Rosemary Lemon Buttons. Yum! and so pretty! http://www.sunset.com/food-wine/holidays-occasions/easy-christmas-cookie-recipes-00400000059782/page3.html

  • I loved your review on the book, Once A Runner, and I am definitely going to get my hands on a copy. It sounds like a book I could devour in a very short time!! 🙂

  • Just ordered the book off Amazon for $14.95 in case anyone else is interested!

  • Ahhh i LOOOOOOVE once a runner!! I was so so happy when it got un-discontinued b/c my sister and I only had one copy and kept stealing it from each other!

  • Yum to the um, those oreos look great. I’d love to make Resse’s cups.

  • Great recipe for homemade Oreos! Definitely something I will make soon. 😀


  • Pingback: Simple Summer Dinners | The Runner's Kitchen()